Legal aid boycott extends to York Region

Legal aid boycott extends to York Region

Accused could ask province to fund defence

York Region, June 11, 2009

Newmarket Era

York Region lawyers and others who practice at the Newmarket courts are now boycotting legal aid cases for some of the most serious criminal offences.

In rare move, the Criminal Lawyers Association announced June 1 that senior lawyers will decline legal aid cases for homicide and gun and gang charges.

By doing so, the association hopes to shine a light on a “notorious imbalance” between the paltry $98 per hour defence lawyers earn from the government for legal aid cases, compared to better resources afforded to police and Crown prosecutors, the association says.

Lawyer Edward Prutschi called the legal aid system “broken” but said he believes lawyers will not abandon legal aid cases they have already taken.

“Consistently, the government’s own experts have recommended substantial increases to the legal aid tariff, particularly as it relates to complex cases handled by senior counsel,” Mr. Prutschi said.

“Evidence suggests that paying senior counsel a fair wage for such cases will be revenue neutral to legal aid’s coffers as it will reduce trial length by narrowing issues and limit the correction of errors on appeal.”

“Our firm does normally accept legal aid cases in Newmarket and other jurisdictions, but we are following the mandate of the Criminal Lawyers Association and declining new legal aid cases where the charges are homicides or arise from guns and gangs project prosecutions,” said Mr. Prutschi, who often practices at the Newmarket courts.

Several lawyers, who have been involved in high-profiles cases at Newmarket, are participating in the boycott, according to the Criminal Lawyers Association’s website, It should be noted that those cases were not necessarily legal aid cases.

A defence lawyer working on a legal aid case earns about $98 per hour, Frank Addario, the association’s president said in an interview.

But, he added, that is before free hours of work and expenses are factored in.

The association has not said how much more per hour defence lawyers should be paid for legal aid cases.

But charity is no way to run a social program, Mr. Addario said.

In a letter to Attorney General Chris Bentley, dated April 17, Mr. Addario said he recognized the world is currently experiencing an economic downturn and that money is being used to maintain existing social programs.

“Legal aid is one of these social programs,” Mr. Addario wrote.

The province has been working hard to ensure the province has a strengthened legal aid system and that those involved are properly compensated, Mr. Bentley said in an interview.

“I think it can be strengthened.” Mr. Bentley said.

The legal aid tariff has increased 15 per cent in the past five years, he said.  But that does not make up for freezes or cuts in the 15 years preceding those increases, he added.

There have been discussions between the association and the province, however, Mr. Bentley would not discuss details.

“We’re all trying to get to a better place,” he said. “Legal aid has never been an easy file for government.”

It is hard to say how long this type of boycott could last, Glenn Stuart, a practicing lawyer and legal aid expert said.

“I think our justice system is still fairly near the head of the pack,” he added.

If someone does not have the money to pay for a defence lawyer who is not taking legal aid cases, they could approach a lawyer who is not participating in the boycott or ask the court to order the Attorney General to fund their defence, he said.

But accused shouldn’t count on getting any breaks, such as claims the boycott violated their right to a speedy trial, Mr. Stuart said.

“I would be surprised if the court would count that against the Crown,” Mr. Stuart said.

Meanwhile, the province has released a seven-point plan to more effectively move what it calls “straightforward” cases through the justice system.

The announcement was made May 27 — five days before the lawyers’ association announced its boycott of legal aid cases and three days after the York Region Media Group reported a sexual assault case had been tossed out a Newmarket court because a defendant’s right to a trial within a reasonable time had been violated.

The seven initiatives were developed after a project at the Newmarket courthouse, as well as courthouses in North York and London.

The Newmarket courthouse, which serves all of York Region, was one of several in this province designated an “action site” to improve the pace of justice. The Ontario court in Newmarket has been mired by procedural delays that have resulted in several cases being thrown out because a judge ruled a defendant’s right to a trial within a reasonable time was violated.

The initiatives are:

• On-site legal aid and a simplified online application process;

• Two-stage disclosure: An initial package that will ensure everyone has information they need to make timely decisions and minimize unnecessary delays;

• Meaningful first appearances: The parties will agree if any work can be done up front so the first court appearance makes progress toward resolving the case;

• A three-appearance standard: The parties will know there is a three-appearance standard for straightforward cases, which will allow resources to flow to complex cases;

• Crown access commitment: All parties will commit to exploring if the case can be resolved early;

• Increased availability of plea courts when someone wants to plead guilty and;

• Direct accountability: Measures to hold offenders accountable to their community rather than going through the traditional court process.

But, Mr. Bentley could not say when those initiative would begin to take effect in Newmarket.

“They are starting to figure out the implementation schedule right now,” he said.

The government has said the action sites, including Newmarket, will each determine the best way to roll out the initiatives to best meet their needs. How those changes are implemented will vary site-to-site.

In a statement, Harold Dale, a Newmarket assistant Crown Attorney, member of the Newmarket local leadership team said the momentum for change is building.

“Taken together, these approaches will speed the pace of justice,” Mr. Dale said.

Mr. Bentley said by 2012, he expects 500,000 fewer court appearances every year simply to adjourn proceedings to another date.

If you need a Toronto Criminal Lawyer, do not hesitate to call Bytensky Prutschi Shikhman at 416.365.3151, we are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week and are on standby.

Our Testimonials

Dod Ndreu
Dod Ndreu
23:22 02 May 20
Edward is an excellent lawyer. He is very professional and hard working criminal lawyer. I hired him for my sons criminal matter as he was looking at numerous charges and some serious jail time. He worked very hard on my sons case and dropped all charges. My son was able to get away with no jail time, thanks to Edwards hard work.. Edward was a godsend to me and my family in the hardest time of my life, and I will never forget. Every thing he told me during the court sessions happened exactly as he had planned them. I would very highly recommend Edward, his work speaks for itself. If you want positive results this is the guy to hire.Thank you Edward for what you have done for me and my family.All the best,Dod
Christopher Seiler
Christopher Seiler
17:20 04 Apr 20
Sonya Shikhman was a total life saver. She took my case in her hands and never left me doubting that I had the best representation I ever could. Thank you for your professionalism, your commitment and accuracy.
Adriano Carpenter
Adriano Carpenter
02:05 04 Apr 20
Sonya is very professional, knowledgable and pleasant lawyer. She was always there when we needed her. She was patient, explained every step of the very unpleasant process and prepared us for every day of the trial. I have been recommending Sonya and her law firm ever since. Thank you, Sonya! Keep up Great Work!
Alex Chalmiev
Alex Chalmiev
11:28 12 Sep 19
The service that their law firm provides is top notch. I had the pleasure to work with Sonya Shikhman she is an incredible lawyer. Very sharp, straight to the point, and gets the job done. It’s very rear that you see the professionalism on that level.
Omar Kalair
Omar Kalair
00:01 15 Jul 19
Edward Prutschi is an excellent criminal lawyer. He took a complex financial crime case where I was facing a long term jail sentence and was able to present a case where the judge acquitted me on all charges. I dealt with two other lawyers who were on record for my file before Edward came on board. With Edward, I found he was always responsive and always willing to listen. He presented a complex case over 5 weeks and was quick on his feet for every twist and turn during the trial. He would be up late the night before witness examination exchanging emails due to new email evidence I was sending him. He would go out of his way to visit potential expert witnesses. He presented a united and coherent defense to the Judge which in the end resulted in my acquittal and the co-accused. With his leading media expertise and being a guest columnist in the Toronto Sun, he wrote an article in defense of my acquittal for those who were questioning the Judge’s decision.
06:41 07 Feb 19
This is by far the best legal representation in Toronto. Sonya Shikhman is tough and brilliant. I highly recommend this firm.
Richard D
Richard D
00:17 24 Apr 18
An excellent lawyer. Edward Prutschi is thorough, non-judgmental and effective. He returns calls quickly and handles everything with a personal touch that puts you immediately at ease. I would highly recommend him
Andreea Felinar
Andreea Felinar
17:01 20 Aug 15
Edward Prutschi is very professional and very helpful. Very patiently, Mr. Prutschi offered me so many detailed responses to my questions. If you need the best criminal lawyer, Mr. Prutschi is the best of the best! Thank you for your efforts, Mr. Prutschi!Cristina F.
Maria konyukhova
Maria konyukhova
15:03 07 Mar 14
Sonya Shikhman is my go-to resource for criminal referrals. She is brilliant in her knowledge and application of criminal legal principles and has a superior understanding of client needs and the most practical avenues to meeting them.
Steven Klein
Steven Klein
15:51 03 Sep 13
I recently referred a client to Ed for assistance. The feedback from the client was excellent. Thanks Ed!
Shannon Stein
Shannon Stein
14:16 11 Jun 13
Ed Prutschi has always been a highly ethical, hard working professional criminal lawyer who gets results for his clients at all times. Our agency, Just For Today Harm Reduction Services, has worked with Ed for nearly ten years and all of our clients feel, as we do, that they have been well served by an empathetic lawyer who places his clients first and foremost.
David Levy
David Levy
21:20 23 May 13
Ed Prutschi is an excellent criminal lawyer. His command of the law and his experience in the Courtroom make him a stellar advocate in any criminal matter. I refer clients to Ed without hesitation because I know they will receive the zealous advocacy they want.
Sharon Shore
Sharon Shore
18:16 15 Mar 13
Ed is an excellent criminal lawyer. He is very professional, extremely responsive and gets good results for my clients. I never hesitate in referring clients to him. Ed has an intimate understanding of how different areas of law intersect with and affect the criminal proceedings. Ed is also a great resource for other lawyers. He is constantly reporting on new case law, and is very knowledgable about cutting edge areas of law.
Lance Lehman
Lance Lehman
18:03 12 Feb 13
Ed’s knowledge of criminal law is first-rate. His analysis is quick and thorough. His integrity is second to none. I never think twice about whom to call when one of my clients has a criminal law issue and I have never been disappointed with the results.
Stuart Rudner
Stuart Rudner
00:03 12 Feb 13
I have known Ed Prutschi since we were in law school together. When I am asked for a great criminal lawyer, I think of Ed because he is well-known for his advocacy and effectiveness in representing his clients’ interests. Ed demonstrates his vast knowledge through his writing and social media efforts, and his record of success demonstrates that he understands what his clients need and the strategies necessary to achieve it. In addition to knowledge and strategy, Ed brings with him a personality that makes people comfortable at very difficult times in their lives. I have referred people to Ed in the past and have never had any complaints, which is important to me. When I refer someone to another lawyer, I never want to hear that the lawyer was unresponsive or did a poor job. Ed always makes me look good.
Next Reviews

Call Now ButtonCall Now to Discuss Your Case.