Toronto Criminal Lawyer Edward Prutschi Discusses Forcillo’s Chances of Appeal

Criminal Law Blog

Back in 2013, a young man named Sammy Yatim was acting erratically on a streetcar, exposing himself to young girls and holding a knife. The streetcar was evacuated and police arrived on the scene, including Officer James Forcillo, who asked Yatim to drop his knife. Yatim didn’t, and Officer Forcillo fired nine shot- three initial shots followed by an additional six several seconds later when Yatim was already on the floor.

In the initial trial, the jury found that while the initial three shots were justified given the situation, the other six were not. Forcillo was found guilty of attempted murder and sentenced to six years in prison.

He has since tried to appeal multiple times, but the courts have continuously rejected the appeal attempted. Now Forcillo is trying to have his appeal case heard before the Supreme Court. Toronto criminal lawyer Ed Prutschi believes Forcillo has a low chance of getting his case heard.

It’s always difficult to reverse a verdict, and Forcillo also has to reverse an appeal verdict, for which Ontario courts unanimously voted to uphold the original verdict. The Supreme Court only looks at a few cases a year, and the cases must be of national importance.

Prutschi states that even if the Supreme Court heard the case and by some slim chance he won, Forcillo won’t walk free. The Crown will almost certainly retry the case. Winning his appeal case would land Forcillo back on ground zero- not freedom.

Share this article

More Recent Articles From Our Criminal Lawyers

BORIS BYTENSKY Criminal Lawyer

At the height of the pandemic, Boris Bytensky helped mobilize an army of defence lawyers to reduce the prison population

  To criminal lawyer Boris Bytensky, the early days of the pandemic unfolded in the correctional system like a giant round of whacka-mole. “We were trying...
Read More

What Does it Mean to be a “Party to an Offence”?

Introduction According to Canadian criminal law, those who encourage or assist in the commission of an offence are just as guilty as the person who...
Read More
Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence

Understanding Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence

Legal consent to sexual activity requires an understanding that consent must be explicit each and every time sexual activity is engaged in with another person....
Read More
Call Now ButtonCall Now to Discuss Your Case.